Ask a contractor what their biggest cost is and you'll hear labour, materials, plant. Ask them what admin costs and you'll usually get a shrug. It isn't on the P&L as a line of its own. It's spread across the QS, the contracts manager, the office manager, the site supervisor writing up the day on the kitchen table at 9pm, and the director who still checks every application for payment personally.
That's the problem. A cost you can't see is a cost nobody owns, so nobody fixes it.
How big is it, really?
Bigger than most people would guess. A few data points worth knowing:
- A Censuswide survey of 162 senior UK and Irish construction finance professionals, commissioned by Payapps, found the average contractor has five people in finance managing 210 subcontractors. Each week that team spends around 20 hours on payment applications, 18 on self-billing, 18 answering payment enquiries and 17 on subcontractor insurance admin. (Construction Intelligence)
- The same research found half of those organisations still manage subcontractor payments in spreadsheets, 46% rely on email and more than one in four still use pen and paper.
- A survey of 688 construction professionals by Procore and Dodge Construction Network estimated that 18% of project time is lost searching for information, which works out at roughly eight working weeks a year. (BDC Magazine)
Treat vendor-commissioned numbers with a pinch of salt, because the people who sell the cure have an interest in the disease. But even if you halve them, you're looking at a part-time role's worth of skilled time every week, in a business with margins that rarely leave room for waste.
Where the time actually goes
In my experience, admin in a construction firm is a hundred small jobs that each look reasonable on their own. They tend to cluster in the same places.
Getting information from site to office
The site diary, the timesheet, the delivery note, the photo of the snag. Most of it gets captured once on site (often on paper or in a WhatsApp group) and then typed up again in the office. Every re-key is a chance for an error, and every error costs more to fix the later it's found.
Getting paid, and paying others
Applications for payment, valuations, variations, retentions, self-billing and chasing. This is where the Payapps numbers bite. It's also the area with the most direct link to cash flow, so it's usually the first place worth looking.
Compliance paperwork
RAMS, inductions, inspection records, subcontractor insurance certificates, CIS. Some of this has hard deadlines. HMRC expects a contractor's monthly CIS return by the 19th, with an automatic £100 penalty the day after, rising from there. (GOV.UK) Nobody misses those on purpose. They get missed because the information was sitting in three places and someone was on holiday.
Finding things
The latest drawing. The signed variation. The email where the client agreed to the change. If your team's answer to "where's that?" starts with "ask Dave", you've found a cost.
How to measure it without a consultant
You don't need software to get a first read. Try this for two weeks:
- Pick the five people who do the most admin. Include supervisors and managers as well as the office staff.
- Ask each of them to keep a rough tally, in 30-minute blocks, of time spent on anything that isn't building, managing the build or talking to a client. Paper is fine. Honesty matters more than precision.
- Group the tallies into the four buckets above: site-to-office, getting paid, compliance, finding things.
- Put a number on it. Hours multiplied by a loaded hourly cost. Then ask the more uncomfortable question: what would those people be doing instead?
- Note the repeats. The same task done the same way every week is the one to look at first.
Most firms that do this are surprised by who is carrying it, more than by the total. It's usually the most experienced people, because they're the ones everyone asks.
What to fix first (and what not to)
Here's where I'd push back on the urge to buy something. The temptation, once you've seen the number, is to go shopping for a platform. Sometimes that's right. Often it's premature.
Start with the boring questions:
- Is the information captured once? If not, the fix is usually agreeing where the single source of truth lives, then connecting what you already pay for. That might be your accounts package, your job management system and a shared drive talking to each other properly.
- Does the process still make sense? Approvals that made sense when you had three sites may not when you have twelve. Removing a step is cheaper than automating it.
- Is it rules-based and repetitive? Then it's a candidate for automation. Chasing missing insurance certificates before they expire is a classic.
- Does it involve reading messy documents? This is where AI genuinely earns its place. It can pull the key details out of delivery notes, supplier invoices or subcontractor applications, with a person checking the output.
Notice that AI comes last on that list. That's deliberate. AI layered on top of a broken process just gets you a faster broken process.
The bit nobody likes to hear
Good records are what keep you paid, compliant and out of disputes, so the admin itself is worth having. The goal is capturing information once, in the right place, by the right person, and not having your best people spend their week moving it around.
Get that in order first, and the technology question becomes much easier to answer.
If you've done the two-week tally and want a second opinion on what it's telling you, that's exactly the kind of conversation we like having.